PHASE 2

Design the Supports

Once the ground work is laid, an organization can both narrow in on where current practices could be enhanced or strengthened with social capital development strategies, tools, and resources and begin to incorporate new opportunities to expand their current reach. Leveraging existing programs, resources, and infrastructure in this work ensures alignment and sustainability long-term and reduces the chances that staff with limited capacity see this as an additional burden.

The second phase of the Cultivating Connections framework includes designing a scope and sequence that sets learning expectations for students, building a strategy for how this scope and sequence gets delivered to students, designing for measurement to support continuous evaluation and monitoring, and building capacity to ensure high-quality implementation and delivery.

Design a Scope

Use the Social Capital Scope & Sequence to identify expectations for student learning that make sense for your organization. Design with the end goal in mind. What do you want all students to be able to do? What should every student be expected to learn and experience in order to get them there? Follow the four-step progression to outline how and when students will:

  • Be introduced to the concept of social capital and its importance 
  • Map their current networks and relationships
  • Be equipped with the skills, mindsets, and tools for building their networks
  • Be empowered to practice their skillsets and advocate for themselves

Use your work from Identify Assets (Phase I) to organize your existing resources and tools and notice where your gaps are. What recommended activities from the scope and sequence might you incorporate? How can these complement your organization’s existing activities?


Build A Strategy: Embed into Foundational Experiences

Create your Pathways Integration Strategy, using your work from Identify Assets and Map Opportunities (Phase I) to follow our three-step guide to integrating the Social Capital Scope & Sequence into pathways. 

  1. Embed expectations into foundational planning and/or academic experiences for all studentsEnsure all students are learning key concepts and developing relevant skill sets by embedding social capital strategies to introduce social capital, map networks, and equip students through required foundational activities. Design considerations should include: 
    • How social capital can be incorporated into career and academic planning requirements, such as through Individual Career and Academic Plans (ICAP)
    • What standards for academic core courses can be met through social capital skill development activities
    • What additional advising and exploration periods (e.g., advisory periods) exist where social capital-oriented lessons and tools might be integrated
Notes from the field
Reach grade-level cohorts of students through required courses

Nashville, Tennessee

LEAD Public Schools in Nashville, TN, integrated the Social Capital Scope & Sequence into their Seminar course required for all students as a social capital “mini-unit,” focusing on delivery to 10th graders across both of their high schools. The team integrated the Social Capital Lesson Plans into the existing Seminar curriculum, which is heavily focused on college and career readiness. The culmination of this “mini-unit” was a series of career conversations with industry partners and LEAD staff. Students put into practice their learning throughout the social capital unit through small group discussions and a larger Q&A session that was driven by their prepared questions that asked the professionals about their educational and career journeys.

Learn more about ESG’s pressure testing and the work of LEAD Public Schools.

Aligning advising models to ensure social capital learning

Tacoma, Washington

Tacoma Public Schools worked to align the Social Capital Scope & Sequence with the PACE (Personalized, Accelerated, Connected, Empowered) advising and mentorship model used with all Tacoma Online students (Tacoma’s virtual school). After several teachers tested the Scope & Sequence within their small PACE groups and 1:1’s with students, administrators mapped strategic opportunities to integrate social capital development, executive function coaching, and college and career readiness tools with the goal of ensuring that students don’t just think about what they want to do, but who can help them get there, and how they’ll take the next step.

Learn more about ESG’s pressure testing and the work of Tacoma Public Schools.


Build A Strategy: Customize Pathways Offerings

Step 2 in a Pathways Integration Strategy: Customize experiences across pathway offerings to grow and mobilize networks. Build on foundational social capital learning by customizing student experiences in pathways-related courses and activities that help them build and mobilize their networks. Design considerations should include:

  • How students can be better prepared for engaging with professionals during career awareness or exploration activities, like job fairs, job shadows, and guest speakers 
  • What opportunities exist within Career and Technical Education (CTE) and other pathways courses for students to practice identifying and reaching to new connections in fields of interest
  • How students might build their networks during early postsecondary opportunities (EPSOs), like dual enrollment and AP courses
  • Where within electives and advanced courses might students map their networks and  identify goals for strengthening their social capital
  • How students can be better equipped to take advantage of work-based learning (WBL) experiences, like internships and apprenticeships, to make new connections and build their social capital skills
  • How students working toward attainment of a credential of value might be connected to credential-holding professionals for mentorship and support as they prepare for their exams
Notes from the field
Integrate social capital content into academic coursework

Nashville, Tennessee

Career and Technical Education (CTE) courses aren’t the only places where students should learn about the value of building and leveraging their social capital. Academic classes can also build relevance and student engagement by incorporating these ideas and strategies. At Maplewood High School in Nashville, the College and Career Readiness coach partnered with the sociology teacher to integrate social capital lessons into their syllabus. Once or twice a week, the coach would come into the classroom and bring a concept (e.g., relationship mapping, strong ties/weak ties, networking) to life, aligning the lesson to what students were currently learning in their existing sociology coursework. 

Learn More
Growing social capital skills and networks for youth apprentices

CareerWise Colorado

CareerWise Colorado developed a short-term, hybrid workshop series to introduce social capital concepts and content with apprentices of varying ages across the Denver region and in different stages within their apprenticeship experience. The team took the materials developed by ESG, such as the Social Capital Scope & Sequence, and adapted them to reflect the style, tone, and vocabulary of their organization. The team also identified other opportunities along the apprenticeship journey where social capital could be a more explicit focus and outcome. This included integration into Business Essentials, a month-long intensive workshop that equips apprentices with professional skills before their first day on the job.

Learn more about ESG’s pressure testing and the work of CareerWise Colorado.


Build A Strategy: Reinforce in Extracurriculars

Step 3 in a Pathways Integration Strategy: Reinforce learning through extracurriculars where possibleWhere possible, reinforce the foundational and customized learning through extracurriculars that take place in- and -outside of school experiences and activities. Design considerations should include:

  • How Career and Technical Student Organization (CTSO) advisors are engaging industry and community partners to discuss aligned postsecondary pathways and career fields
  • What opportunities exist within student clubs, sports, and volunteer activities for students to build their interest-aligned social capital
  • How mentorship programs that involve near-peers, alumni networks, and community members might include a more explicit focus on social capital development
Notes from the field
Elevating student voice to inform design and partnership

Colorado Community College System

Colorado Community College System engaged Career and Technical Student Organization (CTSO) student leaders with prior CTE experience through a workshop held at the CTSO state conference. The session was highly engaging, with students actively participating in hands-on learning activities from the Social Capital Scope & Sequence that introduced them to the concept of social capital and helped them understand how it can be applied to their own lives. Following the workshop, students were invited to complete surveys to provide feedback on their experience that was focused on their favorite and least favorite parts of the social capital lessons, the key takeaways they learned from the lessons, and how the material could be improved to be even easier to understand.

Learn more about ESG’s pressure testing and the work of Colorado Community College System


Plan for Measurement

Consider where social capital can bolster your current measurement and evaluation processes, particularly as it relates to growth and outcomes for students. Review your Pathways Integration Strategy and identify how and when you’ll monitor and evaluate your strategies. Some proposed steps for building a measurement approach:

  • Select a small number of social capital metrics from which to establish an aggregate-level student baseline, set goals, and monitor progress (e.g., can every student identify at least one mentor? What percentage of students feels confident reaching out to someone to discuss postsecondary plans? Did every student’s network grow by at least three people this academic year?)
  • Integrate the review of social capital metrics and progress toward goals into established routines and system-wide evaluations of student outcomes
  • Provide guidance to teachers and staff for incorporating identified social capital metrics into their existing data collection and measurement processes
  • Disaggregate data by student groups to identify any equity gaps in student progress and build targeted supports for those students who may need them
  • Evaluate aggregate-level program standards, routines, curricula, and activities through the lens of student social capital growth to ensure continuous improvement
  • Consider more qualitative methods, like student surveys and focus groups, for documenting successes and challenges

Organizations might also empower students to understand their own social capital growth, through learning how to map their networks, setting goals for themselves, and identifying evidence of growth.

Notes from the field
Develop an avenue for continuous student feedback and input

Chattanooga, Tennessee

The Chattanooga social capital team discovered early on that students enjoyed participating in conversations about their relationships and networks. A focus group intended to be a one-time event became a monthly meeting of a group called the SoCap Student Leadership Ambassadors, who represented all 17 of the 10th grade advisory classrooms. This addition to the pilot plan ensured that the team remained student-focused and provided students with learning and experiences that they wanted. In return, the ambassadors supported and championed the content that was being delivered to them and their classmates during their advisory periods. 

Learn More
Incorporate student reflection into WBL evaluations

NAF

NAF is a national network of career academies that provide career-connected instruction and work-based learning. “Connections” is a key pillar of their outcomes-driven work-based learning framework as they continue to measure and track students’ connections with industry professionals through work-based learning. NAF recently changed their WBL evaluation form to include student-reported social capital measures by asking students to reflect on someone they met with whom they would want to stay connected in the future and what they learned from them. The platform also allows students to take notes on their connections so that teachers can have insight into how their social capital is expanding.

Learn more about ESG’s pressure testing and the work of NAF.


Strengthen Capacity

The adults who support students through their educational journey should be empowered to see themselves as brokers of students’ social capital growth and facilitators of the development of their social capital skills. Develop a professional development plan that considers what role your different adult stakeholders will play in your strategy, the strengths they each bring, and what they may need to be prepared and engaged throughout the year to support students. Some might simply need a “101” training to get started, while others would find it beneficial to go deeper into ideas on mindsets or best practices before engaging with students.

Use the professional development modules co-created by ESG and the Clayton Christensen Institute to design a training that encourages buy-in, customizes for the audience, and equips participants with the skills and mindsets they need. 

Organizations should also reflect on their internal culture and beliefs, which shapes assumptions about students and, as a result, the opportunities that are (or are not) made available to them. Adult mindsets influence the messaging, guidance, and support that young people receive as they navigate and make decisions along their educational journey. There is important work to be done to help adults better understand their prevailing assumptions and strengths as they support a diverse population of students in a way that is culturally responsive and asset-based. The following reflection prompts can help organizations consider how to develop more confident adult advocates: 

  • How can school counselors, career coaches, and advisors support students beyond psychosocial or personal development to help them recognize their current networks, strengthen existing relationships, or form new connections? How can they serve as a source of social capital themselves as students navigate their college, career, and personal journeys?
  • Where are the opportunities for educators and teachers to receive and observe strategies for facilitating social capital growth in the classroom, whether through integration into curriculum or incorporation of relationship-building activities? What common expectations established and support provided to encourage them to see themselves as a bridge for student social capital?
  • What guidance and support do postsecondary faculty need to meaningfully support students’ social capital development in early postsecondary opportunities? Where are there opportunities for them to serve as a bridge to a postsecondary community to better establish a sense of belonging for students before they arrive on their campus? 
  • What explicit expectations and guidance can be developed with community and industry partners when it comes to helping students develop their social capital across different types of experiences? What agreed upon measures will help partners define success?
Notes from the field
Provide staff with what they need to best support students and employer partners

Indianapolis, Indiana

In Indianapolis, Modern Apprenticeship Program (MAP) apprentices benefit from a Youth Apprenticeship Manager (YAM) who serves as their coach, support, and liaison to their supervisor. The YAMS meet regularly with both apprentice and supervisor to make sure the assignment is going well and that all parties are getting the support they need. Before launching the pilot, the MAP team convened the YAMs for a social capital orientation to introduce them to the goals of the project and to outline what this work would mean for them. In addition, to avoid adding more to YAMs’ workload and to maintain some consistency, the MAP team developed a “script” to be used with students and supervisors. The YAMs were given the freedom to make the script more personal but were provided the language to help deliver consistent information to all of their apprentices and industry partners. 

Learn More

Continue to Phase 3: Implement the PlanNext